The recent decision in Christopher Moran Energy Limited v Galileo Empower Limited provides useful guidance on when proceedings involving an English-incorporated company can nevertheless continue in Scotland.
Background
The Court of Session case arose out of a joint venture between the petitioner, Christopher Moran Energy Limited (CMEL) and the first respondent, Galileo Empower Limited (GEL). Together, they operated Dorenell Windfarm Extension Limited (DWEL). The dispute stemmed from DWEL's involvement in the construction of a windfarm near Dufftown, Moray, Scotland.
CMEL alleged that the agreements connected to the project had been entered into without the approvals required under the shareholders' agreement governing the joint venture and DWEL. According to CMEL, the contracts were not approved by DWEL's board and the relevant sub-committee lacked authority to enter them on DWEL's behalf. To prevent further action, CMEL sought interdict and interim interdict (ie injunctions) against the respondents.
However, before the Court could determine those claims, it first had to address a separate issue: jurisdiction.
The respondents argued that the case concerned the validity of DWEL's constitution and decisions of DWEL's sub-committee. Since DWEL was incorporated in England and Wales, they contended that the dispute fell within the exclusive jurisdiction of England and Wales. They also argued that south of the border was the most appropriate forum for the litigation.
CMEL disagreed. CMEL did not dispute that if the matter concerned DWEL's constitution, it should move to the English courts. However, it maintained that the dispute was not about DWEL's constitution. Rather, it was about compliance with the shareholders' agreement and the agreed governance arrangements, and these were matters that could be heard in Scotland.
Therefore, the central issue for Lord Summers was whether the provisions relied upon by CMEL formed part of DWEL's constitutional makeup or whether they merely governed the company's day-to-day operations.
Decision
Constitutional v operational
The Court observed that the documents typically regarded as constitutional are those dealing with matters fundamental to the workings of a company. Obvious examples included a company's articles of association, and matters requiring certain special resolutions or unanimous agreement by members could be regarded as fundamental.
Looking at the relevant provisions of the shareholders' agreement, the Court found that they dealt with practical matters, including:
How and when board meetings should be conducted;
how many and which directors needed to approve board decisions; and
the limits of authority delegated to an operating sub-committee.
These were described as 'operational or administrative in nature.' Two factors further supported that conclusion. First, the shareholders' agreement referred elsewhere to 'this Agreement and the Constitution', suggesting the parties themselves regarded those concepts as distinct. Secondly, the agreement had not been sent for registration at Companies House. While not determinative, it inferred that, at the time, it was not treated as constitutional. The shareholders' agreement also contained a non-exclusive jurisdiction clause in respect of the English courts.
The respondents relied on one of the provisions which expressly included the words 'null and void.' However, the Court was not persuaded that this transformed the dispute into one concerning DWEL's constitution. The alleged invalidity arose from a failure to follow an operational requirement.
In coming to his decision, Lord Summers recognised that shareholders' agreements can be 'hybrid.' They can contain both constitutional and non-constitutional provisions.
The organs of the company
A further argument by the respondents was that the proceedings challenged decisions of the operating sub-committee, an organ of DWEL.
Again, the Court disagreed that this required the dispute to be litigated exclusively in England. Lord Summers observed that the relevant domestic rules deliberately permit such proceedings to be brought where a company is registered, but do not make that jurisdiction exclusive. He described the respondents' interpretation as one that 'flies in the face' of the statutory regime (set out in the Civil Jurisdiction and Judgments Act 1982, Schedule 4).
The suitable forum (forum non conveniens)
The Court also rejected the argument that the English courts were the most suitable place to resolve the dispute.
Several factors pointed strongly towards Scotland:
The windfarm project is located in Scotland;
the alleged wrongdoing was said to have occurred in Scotland;
many of the relevant witnesses are based in Scotland; and
the applicable legislation applies across the UK.
Importantly, no evidence was produced to demonstrate that litigation in England had commenced or would be cheaper, and it was open to the Court to grant interim interdict while English proceedings were contemplated. The possibility that English law concepts such as estoppel (broadly similar to personal bar in Scotland) might arise later in the proceedings was considered too speculative to justify moving the dispute elsewhere.
Lord Summers found in favour of proceedings continuing in Scotland.
Key Takeaways
Where the dispute concerns the validity of a decision of a company, Schedule 4 of the 1982 Act does not give exclusive jurisdiction to the seat of a company.
Where clauses in a shareholders' agreement do not concern matters fundamental to the company's workings but rather look to the day-to-day operational management of a company, they may not engage the exclusive jurisdiction rules.
Importantly, shareholders' agreements can contain both constitutional and non-constitutional provisions, and the use of concepts such as 'null and void' will not automatically convert an operational provision into a constitutional one. Courts will focus on what the clause does and the wider context in which it operates when coming to a decision as to its interpretation.
Factors such as the location of a project, witnesses and alleged wrongdoing will be important when determining the appropriate forum.
For UK-wide joint ventures, particularly in the energy and infrastructure sectors, the case highlights that where a company is incorporated may be only one factor that decides where certain court proceedings can be brought. Parties and those responsible for drafting should be clear not only about how decisions should be taken but also where disputes should be resolved.


